AGL Energy sparks debate with LNG import plan
AGL Energy's confident assessment of the prospects for its potential $250 million LNG import project in Victoria has not been wholly embraced by the market, with some still questioning whether gas can be imported at a price that makes sense for local users.
As chief executive Andy Vesey outlined last week, the venture is moving ahead in the development pipeline, with Crib Point at Western Port in Victoria beating rival options in NSW and South Australia as the preferred site.
But not all are on board with Mr Vesey's view that the project is a "game-changer" for the east coast market, and the timing of a final investment decision in 2019 leaves plenty of room for the market to move against the venture.
Even in today's market, with weak Asian LNG prices and soaring prices on the east coast, some believe the economics don't stake up.
AGL wholesale markets chief Richard Wrightson cited prices of $8-$10 a gigajoule for gas imports if the facility were in existence today.
But adding in distribution costs and a retail margin, prices could still approach $12, depending on the location of a customer, sources say. That's less than the $15-$20 a gigajoule some manufacturers have faced this year, but more than many in the market could bear.
"We remain dubious with the cost at $8-10 a gigajoule," Macquarie Securities said.
"The final investment decision is not before FY19, which means spend of FY20-FY21. In that time the potential is for other gas solutions to defer the decision."
Others disagree. Credit Suisse analyst Mark Samter sees a "material opportunity" for those that can import LNG into the south-east, most obviously AGL, but also potentially others.
Mr Samter says the government's new Domestic Gas Security Mechanism perversely "appears to have opened the door clearly" for LNG importers by effectively enshrining higher prices in the east coast market.
He notes that the mechanism, by targeting Santos's GLNG venture, is based around the "netback" price of GLNG gas, which is the highest-priced gas exported from Queensland.
At an oil price of $US60 a barrel, that netback price allows LNG to be imported into Victoria at a price that is more than $2.50 a gigajoule below the price of gas transported from Queensland, according to Credit Suisse's calculations.
"What we do feel ever stronger about is that importing LNG into the southern states is rational at every level (economically, politically and from a security of supply perspective)," Mr Samter's team told clients in a note.
The project has received warm support from the Andrews Labor government in Victoria even as the government retains its ban on developing onshore gas. The state government promised to work closely with AGL "to ensure approvals processes are streamlined to avoid unnecessary delays and to bring relief to all Victorian gas consumers as quickly as possible".
AGL is yet to kick off the formal environmental approvals process for the venture as it focuses on community consultation at Crib Point, an industrial site with an existing jetty and pipeline easements. Also yet to be decided is the type of LNG import facility, although a spokesman said it would likely be a "FSRU", or floating storage regasification unit, a ship-style floating terminal that could be leased rather than bought.
"We will issue a tender towards the end of the year and let the market decide," the spokesman said.
A new pipeline about 55 kilometres long would likely be needed to connect the terminal to the grid, with a competitive tender also to be held for that, he said.
But the project has already attracted significant interest from potential LNG exporters and traders in the current oversupplied market, with Mr Vesey saying talks had taken place with potential suppliers in the Asian market as well as in Western Australia and the Northern Territory.
Thursday, August 24, 2017
Subscribe to weekly updates
- Batteries, hydro, hydrogen: What are Australia’s best options for renewable storage?
- Investments pays off for Clean Energy Finance Corporation
- Inflated east coast gas prices lifts Origin Energy
- Shorten promises tough emissions targets, but no cap-and-trade
- 'Late out of the blocks': NSW lags Victoria, other states in renewables
- Electricity costs prevent farmers accessing water
- Business to go it alone on energy, climate policy
- Modest member: Go nuclear for a clean energy future
- East coast gas buyers becoming resigned to price hikes
- How regulators short-circuited the energy markets